Loaded Baked Potato Toppings (Make Your Own Bar)

Whether hosting a casual get-together, a family dinner or simply looking for a fun and customizable meal option, a DIY baked potato bar is the perfect solution. With endless topping possibilities, everyone can create their masterpiece tailored to their taste buds, from favorites like bacon, cheddar cheese, and chives to gourmet additions like pulled pork and caramelized onions. In this blog post, I’ll guide you through setting up your own baked potato bar, share mouthwatering topping ideas, and provide tips on how to bake the perfect potato.

Overhead image of loaded baked potatoes with text overlay that says 'loaded baked potato toppings'.

Favorite Toppings
Savory Toppings
Best Potatoes for Baking
How Long To Bake a Potato
How To Make A Baked Potato Bar
FAQS
More Cooking Resources

Favorite Toppings

Melted Butter
Sour Cream
Shredded Cheddar Cheese
Bacon Bits
Chives or Green Onions
Sliced Olives
Ham or Turkey
Diced Tomatoes

Savory Toppings

Chopped Brisket
Taco Meat
Baked Beans
Chili
Guacamole
Caramelized Onions
Sautéed Mushrooms
Pulled Pork
Jalapeños

Overhead image of savory loaded baked potatoes.

Best Potatoes for Baking

The type of potato you pick matters. The best baked potatoes are made with options low in moisture and high in starch. I love using russet potatoes because they fit these qualities and give you a deliciously crispy skin once baked. Idaho potatoes are also a good choice when making baked potatoes. I would skip waxy options, like Yukon Gold, as they won’t create a fluffy inside once baked.

Overhead image of russet potatoes in sack.

How Long To Bake a Potato

I have a detailed blog post about How Long To Bake a Potato at 450 in the Oven. It gives you more insight into my tips and tricks for the perfect, crispy baked potato.

How To Make A Baked Potato Bar

Remember the following tips to prepare a delicious baked potato bar for your guests:

Prepare a variety of toppings to suit all tastes and set them up in bowls with serving utensils. This will allow guests to customize their baked potatoes to their liking.
Make sure to have seasonings available, such as salt and pepper.
You can cut the potatoes in half so they are ready for your guests. Just wait until everyone is ready to eat so they won’t get cold!

Up close image of baked potato with toppings in small bowls.

FAQS

Should potatoes be wrapped in foil before baking?

Foil traps moisture and steams the potatoes, creating a “boiled” taste and texture. Without foil, the skin becomes extra crispy and flavorful.

Are baked potatoes healthier than bread?

Of the starchy and complex carbohydrate foods, potatoes are the healthiest. They are high in fiber, which helps to satiate hunger and regulate blood sugar.

This versatile and interactive meal is perfect for casual gatherings and can easily accommodate different dietary preferences. Enjoy!